A
antihero
was haltet ihr vom Fantasy Epos und dem ganzen Werbezeugs drum herum?
Massenfutter oder perfekt umgesetzte Buchadaption?
Massenfutter oder perfekt umgesetzte Buchadaption?
Dario Linsky
Erfahrenes Mitglied
Zu dem Buch: Genial!
Zu dem Film: Ebenfalls genial, auch wenn der erste Teil eigentlich nur das Geplänkel am Anfang ist. Das Buch ist aber trotzdem besser.
Zu dem Drumherum: Geldmacherei... Die erste DVD fand ich schon ziemlich gut, aber dann drei Monate später noch eine rauszubringen, find ich schon irgendwie dreist.
Zu dem Film: Ebenfalls genial, auch wenn der erste Teil eigentlich nur das Geplänkel am Anfang ist. Das Buch ist aber trotzdem besser.
Zu dem Drumherum: Geldmacherei... Die erste DVD fand ich schon ziemlich gut, aber dann drei Monate später noch eine rauszubringen, find ich schon irgendwie dreist.
AnonymerSurfer
Erfahrenes Mitglied
Buch: Bin noch dran, bis jetzt gut.
Film: Ziemlich geil, jedoch vermisse ich Tom Bombadil
Kommerz: Im allgemeinen ist Herr der Ringe ja noch harmlos im Gegensatz zu gewissen Anime-Tiersendungen die den Markt mit Plastik geflutet haben.
Was ich besonders schön finde, ist dass man den original Ring für 400€ selbst erwerben kann. *spar*
Film: Ziemlich geil, jedoch vermisse ich Tom Bombadil
Kommerz: Im allgemeinen ist Herr der Ringe ja noch harmlos im Gegensatz zu gewissen Anime-Tiersendungen die den Markt mit Plastik geflutet haben.
Was ich besonders schön finde, ist dass man den original Ring für 400€ selbst erwerben kann. *spar*
A
antihero
zum werbetamtam stehe ich eigentlich auch kritisch... ausser zu der dvd welche asphyxia kritisiert hat... die extended edition lohnt sich auf jeden fall. schon nur weil die verpackung mal ziemlich stilvoll daher kommt und ausserdem weil jede der 30 zusatzminuten des filmes absolut fehlt in der originalfassung! die 30 minuten bieten viel an zusätzlicher stimmung und momenten welche der buchleser im film vermisst (zB. elben-zug beim verlassen des auenlandes, frodo und sam).
abgesehen davon, gehe ich mit euch einig, das buch schlägt den genialen film um längen... werde mir in ca. 3 h und 18 minuten den zweiten teil der trilogie im kino ansehen.... JUHUUU!
antihero
abgesehen davon, gehe ich mit euch einig, das buch schlägt den genialen film um längen... werde mir in ca. 3 h und 18 minuten den zweiten teil der trilogie im kino ansehen.... JUHUUU!
antihero
AnonymerSurfer
Erfahrenes Mitglied
Übrigens, ziemlich geiler Dialog aus den IGN Foren, gepostet in den DragonEmpires Foren von Codemasters.
Gatekeeper: Speak friend and enter
Frodo: Enter exit
[Group] Frodo: WTF? Where's the Dwarf King?
[Group] Aragorn: Guess he hasn't popped.
[Group] Merry: Wanna biscuit!
[Group] Gandalf: STFU Merry.
[Group] Frodo: Seriously, there's no Dwarves anywhere. WTF?
[Group] Samwise: Hey a goblin! I didn't know they popped here.
[Group] Frodo: What con?
[Group] Samwise: Blue to me.
[Group] Merry: Pulling...
[Group] Frodo: No! They add!
[Group] Samwise: inc 2
[Group] Samwise: Make that 6.
[Group] Gandalf: More like 20.
[Group] Aragorn: @#%$! Try to get to the zone point!
[Group] Gandalf: On me!
[Group] Aragorn: Tanking 4.
[Group] Galdalf: ON ME DAMMIT!
[Group] Merry: Weee!
[Group] Frodo: Sprint!
[Group] Aragorn: Frodo, Give Gandalf the ring. He can use it to get away then come back and res maybe.
[Group] Frodo: Trade bugged.
[Group] Aragorn: Trade bugged my ass, you just don't want to give it up. Hand it over!
[Group] Frodo: NO! IT'S PRECIOUS!
[Group] Gandalf: Balrog add!
Gandalf kills the Balrog!
Gandalf has just been killed by a Balrog!
[Group] Aragorn: Merry you idiot!
[Group] Frodo: Zoned safely.
_________________________________
[Group] Frodo: Jesus what a pain!
[Group] Samwise: I know.
[Group] Frodo: How many orc adds did we get there?
[Group] Aragorn: About 25 or so.
[Group] Frodo: Where is everyone?
[Group] Samwise: I'm right next to you.
[Group] Boromir: I released. gl guys. Logging.
[Group] Aragorn: Leg, Gimli and I are all together. Where are you guys?
[Group] Legolas: Gandalf never came back after going LD.
[Group] Frodo: Merry? Pippin?
Aragorn sends "WTF? Don't get Merry back, the guy is a moron!"
You send "WTF am I supposed to do? He's still in the grp. He's gonna want to get back with us." to Aragorn
[Group] Merry: Biscuit!
[Group] Pippin: We're surrounded by aggro Orcs. Can't move.
[Group] Frodo: We'll come get you.
[Group] Aragorn: Once we find each other lol.
[Group] Samwise: This is stupid. We're all spread out.
[Group] Legolas: I'm out of arrows. Can we head back to town first?
[Group] Frodo: You idiot. Why didn't you bring enough?
[Group] Legolas: WTF? We were supposed to get on the boat and go down the river. What did I need arrows for?
[Group] Frodo: Gee, I don't know. Maybe cuz you're a RANGER!
[Group] Legolas: Up yours.
[Group] Aragorn: Guys... dont' argue...
[Group] Legolas: Hey, at least I specced my bow. Better than your blade-specced ass.
[Group] Aragorn: Well at least *I* didn't get rid of my Archer's Bracer just to get a +CHA item.
[Group] Legolas: Well, I gotta look good, you know.
[Group] Aragorn: I hate it when people gimp themselves for roleplay purposes. WTF is up with that!?
[Group] Pippin: These orcs are coming a bit closer now.
[Group] Merry: Should I pull one?
[Group] Pippin: If you do, I'll disband and run, you imbecile.
[Group] Merry: Biscuit!
[Group] Gimli: we r ub3r. we shld hunt more.
[Group] Frodo: Gawd I hate leet.
[Group] Gimli: i m w4y mor3 lee+ th4n joo.
[Group] Legolas: Hey, I LIKE having a high CHA. It's important.
[Group] Aragorn: For what!? You're a RANGER. You're a god damn CHA specced RANGER!
[Group] Pippin: /gu god I'm with a stupid group.
[Group] Frodo: ...
[Group] Pippin: mistell
[Group] Aragorn: Look. Let's all just meet up. Frodo what's your loc.
[Group] Frodo: Lets split up and form individual groups. I think that might be best.
[Group] Gimli: d3wd... we all h4ve tha same quest! Why split?
[Group] Frodo: CUZ WE'RE ALL OVER THE ZONE YOU MORON!
[Group] Legolas: I mean, what's the point of not being pretty?
[Group] Merry: Pulling! Wee!
[Group] Pippin: God dammit, Merry!
[Group] Aragorn: Well, you might hit things once in a while, Legolas.
[Group] Legolas: WTF are you talking about? I hit every time!
[Group] Aragorn: Yeah, but you got lucky.
[Group] Legolas: To hell I did! And speaking of gimping yourself what's up with being a human Ranger? Rangers need qui and dex, you know.
[Group] Aragorn: I'm blade specced. I needed the CON more.
[Group] Legolas: And don't even start with me on over-roleplaying. We were all ready to go and you were busy RPing with that elf champ chick back in town.
[Group] Aragorn: Dude. Arwen is my eternal lover.
[Group] Legolas: We didn't have room to group her. Say no and move on. RP on your own time, dude.
[Group] Frodo: Oh to hell with it. I'm logging till the next movie.
Frodo has left the group.
___________________________________________
You have entered Orc Infested Forest.
No monster Target in range.
No monster Target in range.
No monster Target in range.
No monster Target in range.
Members of Fellowship of the Ring currently online:
1. Frodo the Level 1 Stalker in Orc Invested Forest
2. Legolas the Level 23 Ranger in Rivendale
[Guild] Frodo: Hey, Leg. Wanna work on the quest?
[Guild] Legolas: Can't. Busy.
[Guild] Frodo: Busy doing what?
[Guild] Legolas: Looking at myself in a mirror.
[Guild] Frodo: Right. Of course.
Your friend, Merry, has just entered the game.
You have removed Merry from your friends list.
[Guild] Merry: Biscuit!
You must wait 20 seconds to quit. Stand or tyoe /quit to cancel.
[Guild] Merry: Need res.
[Guild] Legolas: Serves you right, you jerkoff.
[Guild] Merry: Frodo! Wanna hunt?
You will quit in 15 seconds.
You send "Frodo is currently AFK." to Merry.
Merry sends "Come on, I need PLing! Biscuit!"
You will quit in 10 seconds.
You send "No, dude. You always pull purples an get us killed." to Merry
Merry sends "Come on! Pweeeze?"
You send "Well, ok. Meet me at the top of Mount doom. I'm going /anon for now. But I'll be there. Just wait for me." to Merry.
Merry sends "Yay! omw."
You will quit in 5 seconds.
logged out.
Für den Fall, dass es nicht zu Thema passt bitte in's Fun Forum verschieben. Danke.
Gatekeeper: Speak friend and enter
Frodo: Enter exit
[Group] Frodo: WTF? Where's the Dwarf King?
[Group] Aragorn: Guess he hasn't popped.
[Group] Merry: Wanna biscuit!
[Group] Gandalf: STFU Merry.
[Group] Frodo: Seriously, there's no Dwarves anywhere. WTF?
[Group] Samwise: Hey a goblin! I didn't know they popped here.
[Group] Frodo: What con?
[Group] Samwise: Blue to me.
[Group] Merry: Pulling...
[Group] Frodo: No! They add!
[Group] Samwise: inc 2
[Group] Samwise: Make that 6.
[Group] Gandalf: More like 20.
[Group] Aragorn: @#%$! Try to get to the zone point!
[Group] Gandalf: On me!
[Group] Aragorn: Tanking 4.
[Group] Galdalf: ON ME DAMMIT!
[Group] Merry: Weee!
[Group] Frodo: Sprint!
[Group] Aragorn: Frodo, Give Gandalf the ring. He can use it to get away then come back and res maybe.
[Group] Frodo: Trade bugged.
[Group] Aragorn: Trade bugged my ass, you just don't want to give it up. Hand it over!
[Group] Frodo: NO! IT'S PRECIOUS!
[Group] Gandalf: Balrog add!
Gandalf kills the Balrog!
Gandalf has just been killed by a Balrog!
[Group] Aragorn: Merry you idiot!
[Group] Frodo: Zoned safely.
_________________________________
[Group] Frodo: Jesus what a pain!
[Group] Samwise: I know.
[Group] Frodo: How many orc adds did we get there?
[Group] Aragorn: About 25 or so.
[Group] Frodo: Where is everyone?
[Group] Samwise: I'm right next to you.
[Group] Boromir: I released. gl guys. Logging.
[Group] Aragorn: Leg, Gimli and I are all together. Where are you guys?
[Group] Legolas: Gandalf never came back after going LD.
[Group] Frodo: Merry? Pippin?
Aragorn sends "WTF? Don't get Merry back, the guy is a moron!"
You send "WTF am I supposed to do? He's still in the grp. He's gonna want to get back with us." to Aragorn
[Group] Merry: Biscuit!
[Group] Pippin: We're surrounded by aggro Orcs. Can't move.
[Group] Frodo: We'll come get you.
[Group] Aragorn: Once we find each other lol.
[Group] Samwise: This is stupid. We're all spread out.
[Group] Legolas: I'm out of arrows. Can we head back to town first?
[Group] Frodo: You idiot. Why didn't you bring enough?
[Group] Legolas: WTF? We were supposed to get on the boat and go down the river. What did I need arrows for?
[Group] Frodo: Gee, I don't know. Maybe cuz you're a RANGER!
[Group] Legolas: Up yours.
[Group] Aragorn: Guys... dont' argue...
[Group] Legolas: Hey, at least I specced my bow. Better than your blade-specced ass.
[Group] Aragorn: Well at least *I* didn't get rid of my Archer's Bracer just to get a +CHA item.
[Group] Legolas: Well, I gotta look good, you know.
[Group] Aragorn: I hate it when people gimp themselves for roleplay purposes. WTF is up with that!?
[Group] Pippin: These orcs are coming a bit closer now.
[Group] Merry: Should I pull one?
[Group] Pippin: If you do, I'll disband and run, you imbecile.
[Group] Merry: Biscuit!
[Group] Gimli: we r ub3r. we shld hunt more.
[Group] Frodo: Gawd I hate leet.
[Group] Gimli: i m w4y mor3 lee+ th4n joo.
[Group] Legolas: Hey, I LIKE having a high CHA. It's important.
[Group] Aragorn: For what!? You're a RANGER. You're a god damn CHA specced RANGER!
[Group] Pippin: /gu god I'm with a stupid group.
[Group] Frodo: ...
[Group] Pippin: mistell
[Group] Aragorn: Look. Let's all just meet up. Frodo what's your loc.
[Group] Frodo: Lets split up and form individual groups. I think that might be best.
[Group] Gimli: d3wd... we all h4ve tha same quest! Why split?
[Group] Frodo: CUZ WE'RE ALL OVER THE ZONE YOU MORON!
[Group] Legolas: I mean, what's the point of not being pretty?
[Group] Merry: Pulling! Wee!
[Group] Pippin: God dammit, Merry!
[Group] Aragorn: Well, you might hit things once in a while, Legolas.
[Group] Legolas: WTF are you talking about? I hit every time!
[Group] Aragorn: Yeah, but you got lucky.
[Group] Legolas: To hell I did! And speaking of gimping yourself what's up with being a human Ranger? Rangers need qui and dex, you know.
[Group] Aragorn: I'm blade specced. I needed the CON more.
[Group] Legolas: And don't even start with me on over-roleplaying. We were all ready to go and you were busy RPing with that elf champ chick back in town.
[Group] Aragorn: Dude. Arwen is my eternal lover.
[Group] Legolas: We didn't have room to group her. Say no and move on. RP on your own time, dude.
[Group] Frodo: Oh to hell with it. I'm logging till the next movie.
Frodo has left the group.
___________________________________________
You have entered Orc Infested Forest.
No monster Target in range.
No monster Target in range.
No monster Target in range.
No monster Target in range.
Members of Fellowship of the Ring currently online:
1. Frodo the Level 1 Stalker in Orc Invested Forest
2. Legolas the Level 23 Ranger in Rivendale
[Guild] Frodo: Hey, Leg. Wanna work on the quest?
[Guild] Legolas: Can't. Busy.
[Guild] Frodo: Busy doing what?
[Guild] Legolas: Looking at myself in a mirror.
[Guild] Frodo: Right. Of course.
Your friend, Merry, has just entered the game.
You have removed Merry from your friends list.
[Guild] Merry: Biscuit!
You must wait 20 seconds to quit. Stand or tyoe /quit to cancel.
[Guild] Merry: Need res.
[Guild] Legolas: Serves you right, you jerkoff.
[Guild] Merry: Frodo! Wanna hunt?
You will quit in 15 seconds.
You send "Frodo is currently AFK." to Merry.
Merry sends "Come on, I need PLing! Biscuit!"
You will quit in 10 seconds.
You send "No, dude. You always pull purples an get us killed." to Merry
Merry sends "Come on! Pweeeze?"
You send "Well, ok. Meet me at the top of Mount doom. I'm going /anon for now. But I'll be there. Just wait for me." to Merry.
Merry sends "Yay! omw."
You will quit in 5 seconds.
logged out.
Für den Fall, dass es nicht zu Thema passt bitte in's Fun Forum verschieben. Danke.
A
antihero
eine halbe stunde früher als ich....
bin auf jeden fall ziemlich gespannt...
antihero
bin auf jeden fall ziemlich gespannt...
antihero
Dario Linsky
Erfahrenes Mitglied
Naja, Tom Bombadil ist im grossen und ganzen ja nicht wirklich wichtig für die Geschichte, also hat man ihn weggelassen. Stattdessen hat man dann noch die Liebesgeschichte zwischen Aragorn und Arwen eingebaut, die man sich meiner Meinung nach hätte sparen können...
Ich hab ja auch nicht gesagt, dass die zweite DVD schlecht ist. Ich fand das nur irgendwie ziemlich dreist, dass man erst noch eine "Sparversion" auf den Markt geschmissen hat und nur drei Monate später dann die Uncut-Version mit tonnenweise Extras nochmal verkauft. Kann auch daran liegen, dass ich damals die Sparversion gekauft hab und jetzt frustriert bin, weil ich sie nicht mehr loswerde...
Ich hab ja auch nicht gesagt, dass die zweite DVD schlecht ist. Ich fand das nur irgendwie ziemlich dreist, dass man erst noch eine "Sparversion" auf den Markt geschmissen hat und nur drei Monate später dann die Uncut-Version mit tonnenweise Extras nochmal verkauft. Kann auch daran liegen, dass ich damals die Sparversion gekauft hab und jetzt frustriert bin, weil ich sie nicht mehr loswerde...
A
antihero
ja da geb ich dir recht, die marketingstrategie ist sowieso ziemlich dreist... nur jedes jahr einen film... dafür dann das ganze jahr lang dvd's und posters und solchen krimskrams... regelmässige appelle ans portemonnaie...
antihero
//edit: lovestory, hätte man von mir aus auch nicht künstlich aufblasen müssen... im vorfeld des zweiten teils, haben sich ja manche zeitungen drüber aufgeregt, das arwen kaum zu sehen ist (jedenfalls sehr spät) im zweiten teil... und tom bombadil bleibt mir lieber in der phantasie erhalten als schlecht in einem film dargestellt...!
antihero
//edit: lovestory, hätte man von mir aus auch nicht künstlich aufblasen müssen... im vorfeld des zweiten teils, haben sich ja manche zeitungen drüber aufgeregt, das arwen kaum zu sehen ist (jedenfalls sehr spät) im zweiten teil...
und tom bombadil bleibt mir lieber in der phantasie erhalten als schlecht in einem film dargestellt...!
